Tuesday, January 20, 2015

Andrew Mellon's Economic Policies

Andrew Mellon was Secretary of the Treasury for more than ten years; he served under presidents Harding, Coolidge, and Hoover. His work helped to pull the United States out of an economic decline, and helped to generate a decade of prosperity for citizens at all income levels.

An insightful economist, Mellon approached his task systematically. Appointed by Harding at the very beginning of Harding’s first term, Mellon inherited a national debt of over twenty-six billion dollars: a staggering sum at the time. Tax revenue was anemic, and Mellon saw that high tax rates were dampening business activity. Cuts to the tax rates would energize business, which would in turn boost personal income for workers, and finally increase tax revenue to pay off the debt.

Mellon encouraged Congress to cut taxes; by 1926, income tax rates had fallen from a high of 50% to 20% in the highest brackets. Further tax cuts would be enacted, and by 1928, the national debt had fallen to 17.6 billion.

During the war, the United States had lent huge sums to various European nations. France, in particular, was teetering on the edge of economic collapse, and Mellon recognized that such a collapse would have ripple effects which would harm the U.S. economy. He achieved an agreement whereby some of debt would be forgiven. He calculated that the amount which the U.S. lost by canceling French debt would be less than the harm generated by a French economic breakdown.

Likewise, Mellon was instrumental to the design and implementation of the Dawes Plan. The plan, named after Coolidge’s vice-president Charles Dawes, stabilized the German economy by restructuring its debt, preventing both the outbreak of war and the serial collapse of several European economies; it was enacted in 1924, and revised in 1929 under the name ‘the Young Plan.’

In addition to cutting taxes, Mellon found ways to reduce government spending. He restructured the way in which paper money was printed, saving taxpayer dollars in the process.

Mellon’s years in government were at a time when a shift was taking place: earlier in history, the government’s revenues were largely from tariffs; later in history, a larger percentage of revenue would come from income tax. Whether Mellon encouraged this change, or whether it was taking place around him and despite him, is a matter open to debate. Did he welcome it, or simply acknowledge it as inevitable?

The tax cuts which Mellon persuaded Congress to pass were carefully calculated to ensure that taxpayers at the very bottom of the wage scale would benefit by being allowed to keep more of their earned wages. Mellon argued that unearned income could be taxed at a higher rate than earned income.

While Mellon agreed with Coolidge and Harding about the broad principles of federal policy, there were some differences. As historian Amity Shlaes writes,

As he got to know the Treasury secretary, Coolidge could see that he and Mellon came at the question of the budget and money differently. Coolidge believed that higher taxes were wrong because they took away from men money that was their property; he believed that lower rates were good precisely because they encouraged enterprise, but also because they brought less money. Low rates starved the government beast.

While Mellon’s policies were successful at rescuing both the American and the European economies, his embrace of a progressive income tax and his willingness to tax unearned income at higher rates than earned income may have planted the seeds for future economic difficulties.

Monday, January 19, 2015

Candidate Harding

Early in 1920, there was a large number of candidates seeking the nominations of both the Republican Party and the Democrat Party. Because President Woodrow Wilson was not seeking reelection, neither party had an incumbent, and the fields were wide open.

The differences between the candidates were sometimes ideological, as in the distinction between Warren Harding and Theodore Roosevelt, but sometimes the contrast was one of style, as in the contrast between Harding and Calvin Coolidge. In terms of policy, Harding and Coolidge were nearly indistinguishable, but in terms of oratory, Harding bested Coolidge in his ability to move crowds.

Harding interested the voters by speaking of an end to experimentation. Wilson’s administration was perpetually tinkering with the economy, with education, and with other policy topics. The voters were annoyed by regulation and by constant changes in regulation. Historian Amity Shlaes recounts a pivotal speech which brought Harding closer to the nomination:

Before a crowd of 100,000 Harding then gave his speech, far grander and more ambitious than Coolidge’s and of high quality. America must not expect too much or experiment too much, he said. He warned against change for its own sake. “No altered system will work a miracle,” he said. “Any wild experiment will only add to the confusion. Our best assurance lies in efficient administration of our proven system.” Harding might pursue some items on the progressive agenda. But he sought no Square Deal, such as Theodore Roosevelt had offered. What this administration wanted was to find its way back to the Old Deal.

After several ballots, the Republican Party nominated Harding. The 1920 election was a landslide. The other party got only 34% of the popular vote, and the only states it carried were the states of the old Confederacy. Civil War sentiments were still in play. A majority of African-American voters in the states of the deep South chose Harding, but the local governments there were in the hands of the Democrats, who kept many Black voters away from the polls, and refused to count some of the votes of those who did cast a ballot.

Harding would repay the electorate’s trust by deregulating markets, cutting taxes, cutting federal spending, and paying down the national debt. The result was a thriving economy, benefiting citizens at all income levels, low or high. Harding also worked to counteract Woodrow Wilson’s racist policies. Unlike Wilson, Harding was in favor of anti-lynching laws. The children of former slaves, the African-American voters of the deep South, had an effective ally in Warren G. Harding.

Sunday, January 18, 2015

Harding Brings Normalcy

President Warren Harding popularized, but did not invent, the word ‘normalcy’ during the 1920 election. Most famously, he used it in a May 1920 presentation which affected the course of that election.

What did Harding mean? As a candidate for office, he was responding to the eight years of the Wilson administration. Those two terms were characterized by what one historian, R. Emmett Tyrrell, describes as “Woodrow Wilson’s excessive regulation of the economy.”

Beyond the economy, Wilson was also convinced that, as commander in chief during WWI, his “authority to exercise censorship over the press is absolutely necessary,” as Wilson said when urging Congress to pass the Sedition and Espionage acts.

Beyond economics and free speech, Wilson’s support of public education was fueled by his desire to control society. He wanted an education, not to give knowledge and skills enabling individuals to create and innovate, but rather to form the beliefs, values, and opinions of individual humans.

Wilson did not want an education which would give the citizen the tools to develop his own thought; he wanted to instill the Wilsonian progressive agenda into into individuals replacing their own thoughts. He did not want an education to empower the individual scientifically, artistically, and economically to design and originate; he wanted an education to transition the individual into a life of government regulation.

One belief of Wilsonian progressivism was that the government should empower “experts” to make decisions and take such choices away from the individual citizen, whether in the sphere of business, art, or natural sciences. He wrote that

“when I had to do with the administration of an educational institution, that I should like to make the young gentlemen of the rising generation as unlike their fathers as possible.”

Warren G. Harding presented himself to the voters as an alternative - as a chance to throw off the yokes and chains of Wilson’s control, to gain more freedom, and live in an atmosphere of ‘normalcy.’

How did Harding envision this “normalcy”? Normalcy was the calm and free foundation which would allow individuals to experiment, to create, and to innovate. A wave of inventions and discoveries - whether in mechanical technology or medicine - would be unleashed during the Harding administration.

Harding’s vision was one of freeing people to think, write, and invent. Both explicitly and by implication, Harding was - as an extension of his vision - more eager than Wilson to see African-Americans exercise their right to vote.

Even radicals would enjoy Harding’s normalcy. It was Woodrow Wilson and his appointee, Attorney General A. Mitchell Palmer, who had ordered the notorious “Palmer Raids” against suspected communists. Harding was much more relaxed about the communist threat. The best way to defeat it, he felt, was not to arrest communists, but simply to show that freedom allowed for a better life than communism could facilitate. Historian Amity Shlaes writes:

One word from the speech hung in the air: “normalcy” By normalcy, Harding did not mean that people should all be normal. He meant that the environment should be normal and relatively predictable. The old progressive swings in policy disrupted too much. A currency that changed value was a problem. Extreme Red-baiting was wrong; now that the war was over, it was time for compassion. Harding had taken a sentiment felt by everyone - that there had been too much upheaval - and broadened it into a plan. Sometimes the country felt normal now; but if it could get all the way back to normalcy then commerce could do the rest of the work. Then the knotty issues of money, prices, and even tariffs could be sorted out.

After Harding took office, the Wilsonian prudes scolded him because he occasionally drank whiskey - Wilson had pushed the Prohibitionist agenda and the Eighteenth Amendment. They were further delighted when several of Harding’s appointees were enmeshed in scandals - although the wrongdoing belonged to the appointees and not to Harding.

In August 1923, Harding died suddenly. His policies and vision, however, continued under the Coolidge administration. Together, the Harding and Coolidge years saw expanding freedom and prosperity for citizens at all income levels and in all demographic groups.

Monday, January 12, 2015

Progressivism and Public Education

The interplay between public and private education has changed significantly over the decades and centuries since 1776. Public schools in the United States did not appear in significant numbers until a century later. It was not until the late 1800s that public high schools were as numerous as private ones.

Prior to 1900, the distinction between private and public schools was mainly one of technical definitions; in practice, the distinction was often quite blurred.

The Northwest Ordinance of 1785 allotted a piece of land - the famous 16th section of each township - to be used for education. In some cases, schools were built on that land; in other cases, the land was sold to finance the construction of a school. Sometimes, the land was leased, and the revenues were used to fund education.

In many cases, the ongoing operation of schools, especially primary schools, was conducted in a way which corresponds neither to the twenty-first century notion of public education, nor to the twenty-first century notion of private education. Churches and clergy were frequently and influentially involved in the management and functioning of these schools.

Local pastors, ministers, priests, and other clerics were often chosen to supervise schools because they were frequently the only people in the county who had university educations. They had learned to read several foreign languages, were familiar with world history, and conversant with poetry and other forms of literature.

The voters of the counties were happy to see educated citizens involved in education, and didn’t mind that they happened to be associated with religious institutions. Even voters who weren’t church attenders or members of churches thought the arrangement proper. They thought that this was a contribution made by one segment of the community for the benefit of the entire community - the expertise of the clergy would benefit all citizens.

Education was provided by a sort of hybrid institution - neither clearly public nor clearly private. But it was clear that it was in no way managed by the federal government. Townships, cities, and counties managed the schools. State governments took, at first, little interest in education.

Around 1900, a shift in perceptions took place. The distinction between public and private education received more attention. Part of this shift was related to the Progressivist movement, led by men like Woodrow Wilson.

Wilson’s vision of progressivism was one of a technocratic paternalistic authoritarianism, in which a corps of elites would guide policy decisions, and the ability of voting citizens to affect policy would be reduced. Progressives wanted to utilize the educational system to sift out this elite class of leaders. Private schools, with their emphasis on charity and equality, would have to be separated from the public schools and pushed to the side. One constitutional scholar, Judge Andrew Napolitano, writes:

Public schools were an ideal place to weed out students in order to create an elite class of people, while relegating the rest to their rightful position in life. Woodrow Wilson stated in a speech to a group of businessmen prior to World War I, “We want one class of persons to have a liberal education, and we want another class of persons, a very much larger class of necessity in every society, to forgo the privilege of a liberal education and fit themselves to perform specific difficult manual tasks.”

Part of Wilson’s agenda was, of course, keeping African-American students out of universities. As president of Princeton University, he did exactly that, with shocking effectiveness. Woodrow Wilson worked to undo fifty years of civil rights progress.

Wilson’s predecessor in the White House, Theodore Roosevelt, had appointed a number of Black officials to high federal offices. Wilson mocked Roosevelt’s decision, using inappropriate and hateful racial epithets to refer to the African-Americans in Roosevelt’s administration.

While Teddy Roosevelt’s record on civil rights had some flaws, Wilson was determined to undo what good Roosevelt had done. Upon taking office in 1913, Roosevelt removed Blacks from significant federal offices, and re-segregated those branches of the federal government which had been desegregated and integrated in the prior decades.

Sunday, December 28, 2014

Roosevelt and the Grape

The political history of Prohibition is complex. Before the Eighteenth Amendment took effect in January 1920, a nation-wide ban on most alcoholic beverages had been enacted and took effect at the end of June 1919.

Oddly, the ban had been legislated on the rationale that the nation’s grains were needed for the war effort. But the war ended in November 1918, more than six months before the moratorium came into force.

In addition, some individual counties and states wrote their own local bans into law.

Wineries, breweries, and distilleries were economically destroyed; distributors of beverages and operators of restaurants and bars were badly damaged in their ability to earn a living. By contrast, organized crime - “gangsters” and the Mafia - flourished.

In March 1933, legislation allowed for the manufacture, sale, and consumption of certain types of beer and wine. In December 1933, the constitutional amendment was repealed, making beer, wine, and distilled liquors fully legal.

But the economy could not instantly fix the devastation done to several different sectors. One historian, Leon D. Adams, writes:

Would the government, which had destroyed the industry, help to restore it? Some members of President Franklin D. Roosevelt’s administration thought it should. There was ample precedent for Federal assistance; the Department of Agriculture had encouraged winegrowing for more than a century, operating experimental vineyards and breeding wine grapes until Prohibition intervened. As late as 1880, the only Federal census statistics of state-by-state grape production were given in gallons of wine made, because the chief purpose of planting vineyards was to grow wine. This was always the case in other countries; nine tenths of the world’s grapes are grown for wine. Shipping of fresh grapes as a dessert fruit was unimportant until after refrigerated freight cars were adapted for fruit shipments about 1887, and the raisin industry remained small until the 1890s.

American vintners were honored by seeing their product served and consumed at official state banquets:

Promptly at Repeal, Eleanor Roosevelt began serving American wines in the White House, restoring the custom that had prevailed until “Lemonade Lucy,” the wife of President Rutherford B. Hayes, stopped it in 1877.

Given that the Roosevelt administration was spending massive amounts of money on various “public works” and “make work” projects, it seemed reasonable if a small sum were spent to encourage the nation’s winegrowing industry. Compared to other massive expenditures on Roosevelt’s projects, agricultural help for the vineyards was an insignificant amount. The science of winemaking, reports Leon D. Adams, found at least one friend in the Department of Agriculture.

Dr. Rexford Guy Tugwell, a member of Roosevelt’s famed “Brain Trust,” made elaborate plans to restore winegrowing as a nationwide industry. Tugwell, who then was the assistant secretary of agriculture, even favored exempting wine and beer from taxation in order to hold down the consumption of hard liquor. In 1933 he sent the Agriculture Department’s Dr. Charles A. Magoon to Europe to collect the newest wine yeast cultures. At Tugwell’s direction, two complete model wineries were built, one at the Government’s giant agricultural research center in Beltsville, Maryland, and the other at the Meridian, Mississippi, research station which served the southeastern states. Both wineries were fully equipped with crushers, presses, underground vats, and there was a brandy still at Beltsville.

But after a massive investment of taxpayer dollars, Democrat Congressman Clarence Cannon of Missouri organized resistance to government’s wine efforts. Both research locations and their equipped went unused.

Saturday, December 27, 2014

The Presidents and the Grape

Quite early in American history, attempts were made to grow vitis vinifera, a family of common European grapevines, in the thirteen colonies, starting with Virginia. Thomas Jefferson, with his many scientific interests including botany and agriculture, tried to get the vine to grow.

Importing wine from Europe was costly. Americans had already begun to brew their own beer, distill various liquors, and make a form of apple wine. But grape wine still eluded them.

George Washington apparently did not devote much effort to establishing wine production in America, content with imported wine and domestic beer. He did distill his own liquor. Historian Leon D. Adams write:

Virginia, as we have seen, was the first of the colonies to cultivate grapes for wine. The attempts to grow Vinifera, which began in 1619 under Lord Delaware, continued in Virginia for almost two centuries. Some of the vineyards succeeded in producing quantities of wine before plant diseases and insect pests killed the European vines. About 1716, historian Robert Beverley won a wager of seven hundred guineas from his neighbors by producing seven hundred gallons in a single vintage from his three-acre vineyard at Beverley Park in King and Queen County. But Beverley apparently made the wine from native wild grapes, which he cultivated together with his few French vines. The only Virginia wines of any note in the eighteenth century were the red and white Rapidan, made by a colony of Germans who settled on the Rapidan River in Spotsylvania County after 1770. George Washington planted a garden vineyard at Mount Vernon, but there is no record of his having made any wine, although he made cider and distilled considerable quantities of applejack. In 1773, Dr. Filippo Mazzei of Tuscany brought Italian winegrowers with ten thousand European vine cuttings in a chartered ship to establish winegrowing in Virginia. Most of Mazzei’s cuttings were planted at Monticello, the estate of Thomas Jefferson, in what is now Albemarle County. For thirty years Jefferson continued trying to grow Vinifera, even importing some of his vines directly from Chateau d’Yquem, and he is said once to have even imported some French soil. An advocate of wine as a temperate beverage, he hoped to establish grape growing as an American industry, and while minister to France from 1785 to 1789, he made his own scientific studies of viticulture and winemaking. Jefferson finally admitted his failure with Vinifera when he recommended in 1809 that native vines, such as the Alexander, be planted instead.

Eventually, successful winemaking would succeed with other types of grapes in the thirteen colonies. The vitis vinifera would find its American home in California.

In due course, vitis vinifera would form hybrids with some of the native North American breeds, and these hearty plants were able to survive outside of California. Later vintners would also graft vitis vinifera onto the roots of native breeds. In the end, forms of vitis vinifera would grow in places like Michigan and New York.

Wednesday, December 17, 2014

North America: Early Settlers Decide for Independence

By the time that the tyrant, George III of England, provoked, by means of his cruel injustices, the colonists in North America into open conflict with the British Empire, those thirteen colonies, and the other regions they controlled in the interior of the continent, were inhabited by diverse groupings of people.

They faced a profound question: would they actively support America’s bid for independence from England?

During the second half of the eighteenth century, enthusiasm for independence fluctuated among the residents of the thirteen colonies. At times, the majority was probably in favor of it; at times, the majority seemed indifferent or even hostile to the idea.

Polling data as it is known in the twenty-first century was not collected in those days. Estimates of support are made from what evidence exists. Such approximations are not exact.

It is, however, clear that support for independence varied from region to region, and varied within region by ethnic and religious groupings. Historian Thomas Sowell writes:

While other Americans split into Tory supporters of England and revolutionaries for independence in 1776, German Americans split into pacifists and revolutionaries. Mennonites and other German religious sects would not fight, but some paid extra taxes instead or engaged in medical or other duties consistent with their status as conscientious objectors. However, the largest denominations among Germans, the Lutherans and the Reformed, had no prohibitions against the military, and many Germans from these groups fought in the revolution.

Support for the independence effort varied with the colonial army’s victories or losses, with the economic impact of the war, and with shifting political moods. Stirring texts, like Thomas Paine’s Common Sense and The American Crisis stoked the passion for independence; news of betrayal and defection, like that of Benedict Arnold, muted such fervor. Larry Arnn writes:

In the period leading up to the American Revolution, loyalists or Tories contested with revolutionaries, and these two groups alternated having the upper hand between 1763 and 1776, and even later, after the war had begun. The people were making up their minds about something fundamental, and a consensus was slow in forming.

Ultimately, the spirit of independence took permanent hold. A unique turning-point in world history, the United States would find the legitimacy for its founding, not in the hereditary claims of a royal dynasty, but in the consent of the governed.

Working out this Lockean vision, the inhabitants of the new nation reconceived citizenship and participation. Mark Levin describes this notion:

In the civil society, the individual has a duty to respect the unalienable rights of others and the values, customs, and traditions, tried and tested over time and passed from one generation to the next, that establish society's cultural identity. He is responsible for attending to his own well-being and that of his family. And he has a duty as a citizen to contribute voluntarily to the welfare of his community through good works.

In making a decision for independence, then, the residents of North America were making more than a decision about the sovereignty of a particular territory. They were making a decision about personal political liberty and the personal responsibliity which is necessary to maintain it.